THE fan blog
Contact: irina.stanescu@ymail.com
round minus
round plus

My Faust #2, ROH, September 18


Angela Gheorghiu as Marguerite in Faust at Royal Opera House, September 18 - curtain call
.
Faust at ROH, first night. This is Faust #2 for me and if I think back to the dress rehearsal, #2 was better in terms of general feeling, the connections between the characters and the power of music. There were some small changes here and there, the one that I enjoyed most begin Faust&Marguerite's duet in a proper, romantic posture, sitting on the steps of the house (not lying on them which must have been pretty uncomfortable) and less hugs and kissing. There’s still the issue I have with pulling up her skirts at end of this duet as in my mind it doesn’t match the idea of a perfect, inocent first date. But maybe it’s just me.

The church scene was impressive, with Marguerite’s prayer and the scary curse cast by Mephistopheles. David McVicar chose to put this scene at the beginning of act 4, not in the end, after Valentin’s death. I still like a lot the last 15 minutes. I can stand through the entire opera several times only to listen to that part. Because you get to a point where everything explodes. There’s something in that dim atmosphere, holiness after an entire act in the devil’s realm, there’s Marguerite’s “Anges purs, anger radieux”. That was the moment I loved Angela’s voice (with all the colors, emotions and rising intensity contained in it) and acting best. Such a pity that this part is so short. The accelerated pulse was a sign that I really enjoyed everything, from the moment she got on stage in the fifth act to her death and last notes of the orchestra.

I liked that Vittorio Grigolo was … less exuberant than the previous performance (Faust only gets younger but he still has the mind of a grown up man, right?) and more focused on singing. I felt the need of more involvement from his side in "Salut demeure chaste et pure". This aria is about love. It should sound like that. While watching his Faust, I had a vision of his Des Grieux, that young, jumping-up-and-down character in the beginning of the opera. Well…  But all in all he was ok, without convincing me as he did in Manon last year.

Hvorostovsky seemed a little bit stiff. Somehow more concentrated on himself than on interacting with the others. Nice voice, not very powerful but I already knew that from his Onegin in Vienna. Glad to see him again on stage. And speaking of Vienna, the power and emotion delivered by the chorus after Valentin’s death in that 2008 Faust was simply amazing and above what I heard last evening.

Rene Pape was Mephistopheles, frightening, devilish, funny when wearing the dress in act four. He appears and disappears in key moments and changes the lives of the people that get in touch with him. He even managed to keep the tempo in the second act when the orchestra and chorus were on different bars. Loved the voice and the character he created.

I’m still not into the ballet. I must admit though that McVicar’s idea of presenting Walpurgis night is brilliant. it's hard to describe. It's better to buy the DVD or go to the cinema to get what I'm saying. But the more I see the opera, the more I understand this ballet part so who knows… I might end up really liking it. Oh, and I have to point out that I find the sets beautiful. On DVD everything seems smaller. In real life, the sets occupy the entire stage and have a great contribution to creating the atmosphere.

Thinking of this Faust as a whole, there was something missing in order to be THE one. Maybe because it was the first night everybody held back, saving some of their energy for the other performances... I'm so thankful for being able to see it live, because a live performance inside Royal Opera House can't be compared to anything else. As I’m not a professional, what I say usually relates to the feeling a certain performance gives me. And this one told me there’s place for more. So I’m thinking of giving it another try, sometimes soon.
.
Faust at Royal Opera House, September 18 - curtain call
From left to right: Daniel Grice, Michele Losier, Dmitri Hvorostovsky, Rene Pape, Angela Gheorghiu, Vittorio Grigolo and Carole Wilson
.

4 comments:

  1. you wrote: "It's better to buy the DVD or go to the cinema to get what I'm saying." So there will be a DVD of this? Wow!

    ReplyDelete
  2. you must have goooood eyes. i read a few reviews on that Faust and Hvorostovsky, everybody praising him and nobody noticed any stiffness.Great you have so much interest in his performance and noticed that:), you are maybe the only one and unique....

    ReplyDelete
  3. I don't think so. I meant the DVD already released, with the 2004 production.

    ReplyDelete
  4. you have seen Trittico the night before , you know what it missing.. it starts with P and ends with o ;-) but it was good really, just some small tweeks and less singing to the audience and more stick to the character and sing to your partner would do it :-)from mainly tenor and baritone i mean ;-)

    ReplyDelete